Mumbai: Salman Khan, the bollywood superstar, shocked by his sentence of five years for culpable homicide not amounting to murder, reportedly sat down and cried in the court, but it was not clear for whom – the victims of his misconduct as proved by the court, or his caged future, or his producers who were reportedly set to suffer nearly 200 crores in losses, or the millions of his fans who love him for the entertainment he provides.
His defence team that had obfuscated justice since 2002 finally lost their battle for his freedom, thirteen years after the incident that killed one and injured four others, sought an order copy with the intention to move the High Court by the afternoon (The High Court is expected to hear the plea at 4pm today) – to prevent him from being taken to the Arthur road jail that ironically, once held the prime witness in the case, and Salman’s bodyguard, ex police constable Ravindra Patil.
The case related to the death of one person and injury to four others caused by Khan running over them outside a bakery in Bandra in his white Toyota Land Cruiser early on September 28, 2002 allegedly under the influence of alcohol.
Ravindra Patil, the Mumbai police constable, who was assigned to protect him after he complained of threats to his life, ultimately became the pivot around which the entire case revolved as he was in the vehicle at the time of the accident, and he consistently maintained until his death, due to tubercolosis in 2007, that it was Khan behind the wheel that night, and that he was inebriated.
It was Patil who lodged an FIR against Khan, and in his statement to the earlier court which heard the case, said he had warned the actor to drive slowly since he was in an inebriated condition. However, Khan did not heed the warning, Patil had said. He was the prime witness, and therefore the prime target of a campaign to get him to alter his case clinching statement. The judgment therefore, is both a victory of justice and for Patil, who from all accounts of his life, suffered tremendously and ultimately died due to his steadfast evidence against the actor in the case.
Those in favour of Salman, whether in the police force or in his defense team, wanted him to modify his statement slightly to say that “Salman leaned back to listen to him seconds before he lost control of the wheel. This would mean that the accident was caused by a ‘human error’ and not because he was drunk” or state under oath that “Salman was not drunk at the time of the accident”.
Patil did neither, and suffered. He went into hiding and reportedly avoided the court summons to appear. He was arrested after being tracked down in 2006 and was sacked from the police force later that year. In August 2007, Patil was found on the streets near Sewri in a very sick condition, and admitted to hospital where he died in October that year. He had been suffering from tuberculosis for two years, and his family had abandoned him.
The story of constable Ravindra Patil is perhaps the more important narrative in all the hype surrounding the conviction of Salman Khan for at it’s core is the essence of justice – uphold the truth at all times.
His story as summarized above, is narrated by a blogger Soumyadipta Banerjee, a film critic and journalist writing on Indian commercial Cinema in his blog BollywoodJournalist and a Facebook page –Bollywoodbingo, a community that supports the blog. Truth be told, he too came under pressure to remove the blog, which he did, but not before it was picked up by the FB page “The Frustrated Indian” who posted it on their page on June 29 2013.
The blog is reproduced below.
“Ravindra Patil: The death of a messenger
In India, the testimony of the prime witness is considered the most important document in a criminal case, which often influences the final verdict.
In the 2002 hit-and-run case of Salman Khan, the man who found himself in the epicenter of the controversy, was the prime witness of the case — constable Ravindra Patil.
Those close to Patil admitted that he was under enormous pressure to change his statement.
There were many who wanted Patil to change his statement. They preferred that Patil maintain that Salman leaned back to listen to him seconds before he lost control of the wheel. This would mean that the accident was caused by a ‘human error’ and not because he was drunk. Some people wanted him to say that Salman was not drunk at the time of the accident.
Whatever be the case, Patil did not change his statement till the last day.
It was unclear who was putting pressure on Patil — some say they were all ‘well-wishers’ of Salman Khan from the police force while others say that those talking to Patil were Salman’s common friends from the film industry. Whoever they were, the pressure tactic seemed to be working as Patil was showing signs of a nervous break-down.
Why was Ravindra Patil so vulnerable?
Patil was a constable and hence belonged to the lowest rung in the police force. He admitted numerous times that he was under pressure and he would always try to duck the media.
During 2006, when the examination of witnesses was on, Salman had hired the best lawyers in Mumbai who were all charged up to cross-examine Patil. But then, something unexpected happened. Patil just ran away one evening. His brother lodged a missing report about Patil at a local police station.
Day after day, Patil chose to skip court dates because he didn’t want to face the defence lawyer. Soon, Patil came under scrutiny of the court because he remained absent at the court hearings. The court proceedings were stuck because Patil was absent in the witness-box. It also came to light that he had run away without applying for leave.
In a strange twist of fate, a man who had actually lodged the first information report against Salman Khan now had an arrest warrant issued against him for not turning up at court hearings. The arrest warrant was issued after he failed to appear for five consecutive court dates.
As the judge ordered that he be arrested and produced in court, his seniors at the police force simultaneously approved that Patil be sacked from his job because he was absent from duty. His seniors chose to ignore the fact that technically Patil was ‘missing’ and not ‘absent’ according to their own records.
Nobody was interested in knowing why he had run away from his house. Or, why the same person who was so forthcoming in lodging a complaint against a Bollywood star like Salman Khan, didn’t want to take the witness-box. Patil was never put under any witness protection programme.
Patil was sent to Arthur Road jail with hardened criminals
Like how they deal with a hardened criminal, a task force was prepared to nab Patil and find out where he was ‘hiding’. Finding him was easier than anybody had thought because Patil was not hiding anywhere. Ravindra Patil was actually staying in a small hotel in Mahabaleswar, just a few kilometres away from Mumbai. He would come to Mumbai often to meet his wife and family. He was not on the run from the police and was going around telling everybody that he wanted to stay away from the Salman Khan case.
He had repeatedly requested his colleagues in Mumbai Police to work out a way so that he can be spared from the case. The problem was: He was the prime witness and without him the case didn’t stand a chance in a court of law.
How many of you hate going to court? How many of you don’t like how witnesses are grilled in criminal cases by defence lawyers? Well, if I go by Patil’s example, then all of you should be put in jail. Believe it or not, Ravindra Patil was sent to jail because of this ‘crime’.
The special police team swooped down on him, arrested him and produced at the court, the next day. The court sent him to Arthur Road jail, the biggest jail of Mumbai where most of the high-profile criminals are lodged.
In Arthur Road jail, Ravindra Patil was incarcerated in a separate cell like they would treat an armed dacoit or a serial killer. Patil submitted fervent pleas that he doesn’t want to be grouped with criminals at the Arthur Road jail but the court was in no mood to relent.
Twice, Patil filed applications saying that he is a witness and that he be held at Unit nine of the Crime Branch and twice the court ignored the application. In his applications, Patil went on record saying that he went absconding as he was mentally disturbed at the thought of being cross-examined by defence lawyers. But nobody seemed to be interested in what he was saying.
If the courts didn’t pay heed to his pleas, his employers — the Mumbai Police — seemed to be on some revenge spree. A ‘missing’ Patil suddenly became an ‘absconding’ Patil in their own files and subsequently sacked from his job. This junior-most employee in the force tried every trick in the book to convince his senior officers that he should not be sacked from his job. But nobody was ready to listen.
A witness was suddenly at the receiving end of it all. Life was dealing this grand witness blows after blows while Salman Khan delivered hits after hits at the box office.
The last days of Ravindra Patil
After Patil was let out of jail, he found himself in a strange situation — his family had disowned him and the Mumbai Police was not ready to take him back. Patil didn’t know what to do — suddenly he was the victim because he saw the accident and spoke about it.
A broken man by then, Ravindra Patil went missing again.
Patil was finally discovered at the Sewri Municipal hospital in 2007. Patil was begging on the streets of Mumbai before he landed up at the hospital. The years of acute stress coupled with heavy drinking had made his body weak. Worse, he had contracted a drug-resistant tuberculosis which fast tracked him towards an inevitable end.
Patil wanted to get back in the police force but he was just a bag of bones lying on bed number 189 of ward number four on the fourth-floor of Sewri TB Municipal Hospital. His family members were not aware where he was and nobody had come to see him for a year.
Constable Ravindra Patil died on October 4, 2007.
Even after his death, there was nobody to take back his body. The friend who had admitted him to the hospital was so scared that he didn’t even inform his family. In the end, his brothers came forward to perform the last rites.
Before his death, Patil spoke to his friend expressing his wish to get back to the force again while throwing up blood on the cold floors of the Sewri Municipal hospital.
“I stood by my statement till the end, but my department did not stand by me. I want my job back, I want to survive. I want to meet the police commissioner once,” were his last words.
Clearly, even God chose not to hear him.
Ravindra Patil never rested in peace”.
News Report:
Bollywood star Salman Khan convicted under culpable homicide in 2002 hit-and-run case
